Public Policy
  Analysis, opinion & ideas from Steve Harry

Directory

About/Contact

Transparency lacking with Mayor's Neighborhood Advisory Board

November 4, 2021; updated again November 6, 9:50 PM

 

 

In statement made earlier today, I said I could be wrong in expecting the Mayor's Neighborhood Advisory Board to publish meeting minutes. It was pointed out to me that meetings of purely advisory boards and committees are not subject to the Open Meetings Act, a state law. However, someone since has pointed out that the City of Lansing's own ordinances mirror the Open Meetings Act. The meetings of all boards must be open to the public and the "minutes of all board meetings shall be filed in the office of the Clerk as a public record." Article 5, Chapter 1.

 

 

Mayor Schor's Neighborhood Advisory Board gets a failing grade for openness.

 

In an October 18 opinion piece in the Lansing State Journal, DeLisa Fountain, director of Lansing's Department of Neighborhoods and Citizen Engagement, said

 

 

The Neighborhood Advisory Board will host a public meeting at Letts Community Center on Thursday, October 21, from 6-8 p.m. to kick off the application process for Neighborhood Grants and Neighborhood Programs in 2022.

 

 

I attended that meeting, arriving at 6:00. The meeting had already been in progress for a half hour. The NAB website now says meetings are the 3rd Thursday of each month at 5:30.

 

The NAB meeting was not on the meeting schedule for the week of October 18 sent out by city council office manager Sherrie Boak on October 15.

 

On the City website, links to agendas and minutes of boards, commissions, authorities and city council are all in one place. The Mayor's Neighborhood Advisory Board is not listed:

 

 

On October 14, I sent DeLisa Fountain an email:

 

 

DeLisa, I'm looking for the meeting minutes of the Neighborhood Advisory Board. Are they on the City website? If so, could you send me a link or tell me where to find them? I  couldn't find them under Agendas and Minutes.

 

 

She has not replied.

 

On October 18, I sent the city attorney a Freedom of Information Act request:

 

 

I would like the meeting minutes for each meeting in 2021 of the Mayor's Neighborhood Advisory Board. I couldn't find the NAB on the Agendas & Minutes.

 

 

This was the response:

 

 

In order to determine whether the City possesses records responsive to your request, we are extending the time for responding to your request by ten (10) business days, as permitted under MCL 15.235, Section 5(2)(d). Therefore, a written response will be issued on or before November 09, 2021.

 

 

Michigan's Open Meetings Act says

 

 

A public body shall make proposed minutes available for public inspection within 8 business days after the meeting to which the minutes refer. The public body shall make approved minutes available for public inspection within 5 business days after the meeting at which the minutes are approved by the public body.

 

 

The webpage of the Mayor's Neighborhood Advisory Board would be a good place for a link to the NAB's meeting minutes.

 

On October 22, I sent DeLisa another email:

 

 

DeLisa, you said last night that 3 grant projects are on hold. Can you tell me which ones those are?

 

 

She has not replied.

 

The purpose of the NAB is to hand out money. From their website:

 

 

Overview

The Mayor's Neighborhood Advisory Board (NAB) is made up of a group of individuals from each ward that provide support and guidance to neighborhoods and other organizations regarding the possibility of receiving a grant. The NAB member works with any group within their ward to provide guidance from start to finish and make sure all questions are answered; issues are solved; and their end goal is achieved.

Grant

The NAB grant is a tool to help groups obtain funding for many types of projects, events, functions that will enhance their area, and bring people together in a positive setting. The creativity is endless in how the funds are spent as long as they follow the simple guidelines within the application. At the end of their project a "Final Report" is due on what the funds were spent on, information on the event, how many attending, and the impact it had on the group. This report is mandatory for each participating group so we can track how the funds are spent and whether the project was beneficial.

Any registered civic organization or active neighborhood watch can apply for a neighborhood grant. Neighborhood organizations, associations and watches are the preferred grant recipients. All projects must impact a neighborhood in the City of Lansing. Your organization will be notified if you have been selected to receive a grant or if your application was denied. Once the project has been completed your organization is required to complete the Grant Final Report.

The grant cycle begins in October which gives each group time to plan their projects and "fine tune" any changes before submitting their application in February and funds are distributed in April.

Neighborhood Grants Forms

 

On the above list of forms on the NAB website, the only one for which there is a link to the form itself is the Civic Registration Form. The other links were created by me as a public service. The forms were in a packet passed out at the October 18 meeting. I scanned them to create digital copies. I also scanned the extremely detailed, 40-page Neighborhood Organization Resource Handbook and the Grant Application Guidelines.

Note: I've been informed that several of the forms are available here on the city website, and they can be filled out and submitted online.

The inadequacies of the NAB webpage probably should not be blamed on the Department of Neighborhoods and Citizen Engagement. The City launched a new website the week of June 7 and there have been lots of problems. The website was built by CivicPlus, a firm located in Manhattan, Kansas which - according to their website - specializes in technology solutions for local governments.

 

The NAB has about $60,000 to hand out. The NAB webpage would be a good place to present an accounting of what happens with that money. For each grant approved, it could give the amount, the name of the neighborhood group/organization, the application and the Grant Final Report. The people of Lansing deserve to know where their money is going.

 

Also of interest would be the applications that got turned down. Or are "on hold".

 

A list of NAB members is here on the City website, along with members of other boards, authorities and commissions. Don't expect it to be up to date.

 

Send comments, questions, and tips to stevenrharry@gmail.com or call or text me at 517-730-2638. If you'd like to be notified by email when I post a new story, let me know.

 

Previous stories